Audit Report

tmaker.io

AI-powered design critique and glow-up.

Original website screenshot
Redesigned website mockup
Minimalist Tech Solopreneur
Value Proposition68
Visual Hierarchy74
CTA Effectiveness92
Visual Design78
Trust Signals95
Scannability85

Priority Fixes

  • Value

    Rewrite the sub-headline to focus on user benefit, e.g., 'Learn the exact frameworks I used to build and sell startups to $8m ARR.'

  • Visual

    Increase the font size and weight of the main 'Hey I am Tibo' greeting to ensure it is the clear starting point of the page.

  • Trust

    Move the 'Maker of the Year' or '$8m ARR' stat closer to the newsletter signup box to increase conversion through proximity.

Deep Dive Analysis

Value Proposition

68
68

The value proposition is clear regarding the topics covered, but it lacks a specific, outcome-driven hook. It describes what Tibo does rather than what the user gains by subscribing.

Evidence

"'I talk about personal branding, product growth, and more'"

Visual Hierarchy

74
74

Good use of proximity and centering. However, the 'Tibo's Newsletter' title inside the card is nearly as prominent as the main greeting, creating a slight competition for the primary focal point.

Evidence

"Intro headline 'Hey đź‘‹ I am Tibo,' vs card header 'Tibo's Newsletter'"

CTA Effectiveness

92
92

Excellent CTA. The pink color provides a high-contrast 'pop' against the white background. The micro-copy 'Subscribe (free)' reduces friction and clarifies the cost.

Evidence

"Pink 'Subscribe (free)' button"

Visual Design

78
78

The design is clean, professional, and uses whitespace effectively. It follows a modern SaaS aesthetic with rounded corners and subtle borders, though it feels slightly safe/templated.

Evidence

"Centered card layout"

Trust Signals

95
95

This is the strongest part of the page. Citing $8m ARR and the 'Maker of Year' award provides massive instant credibility that justifies the newsletter subscription.

Evidence

"'grew them to $8m ARR'"

Scannability

85
85

The page is very easy to scan. The use of bullet points for achievements and bold headers allows a user to understand Tibo's 'street cred' in under 3 seconds.

Evidence

"Bullet points under 'Cool things I did:'"

Constructive Feedback

The headline 'I talk about... and more' is the 'and stuff' of value propositions—it's too vague to be a hook.

The italicized sub-headline is so light it looks like it's trying to apologize for taking up space.

Your 'Cool things I did' section is actually 10x more interesting than your hero section; why is it buried below the fold?

A hot pink CTA button on a monochrome site is like wearing neon sneakers to a funeral—effective, but a bit of a shock.

The newsletter card says 'No ads, no sponsor,' but the 'Current Focus' section right below is basically an ad for your own products.

How does tmaker.io stack up?

The taste score compared to other audited sites on the leaderboard.